I loved the goth girl belting out Phantom of the Opera.....

That was last night wasn't it? lol
When is it on again? Did I say that???? :)

Not that I will watch it....I want to know when to avoid it ;)

Right on Lixy about that one guy....real big feat to sound better than James Brown! There's another guy that ranks up there with Gene Simmons...ewww

It's on again tonight... 7 Central - FOX. :)

it was - how shall we say, interesting?

I can't believe some of these people who actually think they can sing? Does anyone think they will change their mind once they see themselves on tv?

Well, tonight the first of the final 12 will be dismissed. Any guesses as to who it might be?
My guess is that it will be one of three females. Either Lindsey Cardinale, Mikalah Gordon, or Jessica Sierra. I won't be sorry to see either of them go.

Good job, SS!! And I personally am ready to see Mikalah go... she reminds me sooo much of Fran Drescher, and I find them equally obnoxious and annoying.

I agree, Maddy. She's very annoying.

They're about to announce the one who leaves tonight. But I won't post anything untill the Pixies out West get to see. Don't want to spoil the surprise for anyone.

I agreed with the bottom 2 tonight and hope the one who got to stay, goes next week (Don't think that gives anything away.....;))

No, that doesn't give anything away at all. And I have to say I had guessed the outcome last night.

I didn't hear them announce what next week's theme is going to be. Did anyone notice if they mentioned it?

I was on the phone will someone please PM me and tell me who got dissed....tell me what they look like it's too early to keep up with names.:p

Theme is Billboard #1's...and I agree with who got voted off tonight. I think the other is gone next week.

Thank You!
 

As a HUGE American Idol fan who also happens to live almost as far West as possible while still living in the mainland, I sincerely thank you all for your consideration of me and my fellow West-Coasters. Thank you very much for not saying who got voted out tonight!!!

I agree with the bottom three... but I think the wrong person left tonight.

((((Pixies Idol Fans))))

They are only through 4 so far... and I'm generally impressed with the performances so far... Carrie Underwood! Amen!

OH MY GOD!!! Mikalah just finished performing and it was bad!! The worst of the night so far. All the others have been really good, but I sincerely believe unless someone in the last few really screws up, she's leaving tomorrow.

She should never have made it as far as she has.IMNSHO

She had a few good performances early on, but instead of improving she's regressing. I've never been overly fond of her. I think one Fran Drescher is more than enough. I won't be the least bit sorry to see her go, whenever it happens to be.